Lanterns Just Rewrote Hal Jordan's Worst Comic Moment

The latest episode of HBO's Lanterns, titled "Lights Out," has plunged Hal Jordan and John Stewart into a profound state of conflict, showcasing a level of distrust that feels particularly jarring given their heroic status. As the villainous Antaan confirms Zoe's identity as the Manhunter and launches a devastating attack on Rushville, Hal and John find themselves locked in a bitter feud, their bickering nearly as destructive as the enemy onslaught. This episode marks a significant nadir for their partnership in the series, a disappointing dip in quality for a season that has otherwise been a compelling watch.

However, "Lights Out" doesn't represent the absolute worst moment for either Green Lantern, especially when we consider their extensive comic book histories. John Stewart's own journey has seen darker days, famously marked by his arrogance leading to the catastrophic destruction of the planet Xanshi. Yet, for Hal Jordan, the sting of "Lights Out" pales in comparison to the infamous "Emerald Twilight" storyline. This era in the comics saw Hal's descent into villainy, a dramatic and traumatic period that has long been a sore spot for fans debating his character's portrayal across different media.

Hal Jordan's Comic Book Low Point

Discussions on any Green Lantern fan forum inevitably touch upon the controversial arcs of Hal Jordan. Even in his early days, as depicted in the beloved Green Lantern/Green Arrow series of the 1970s, Hal was often criticized for his rigid adherence to authority, a trait that some fans saw as "bootlicking." He frequently grappled with disillusionment regarding his superhero life, often retreating into periods of personal turmoil. But these personal struggles were dwarfed by the seismic events of "Emerald Twilight," where, driven by grief and madness, Hal destroyed the Green Lantern Corps and became the villainous Parallax. The show's "Lights Out" offers a dramatic conflict, but it's a far cry from Hal's comic-book nadir.

John Stewart's Controversial Reimagining

Meanwhile, Lanterns has also courted significant fan debate with its radical reimagining of John Stewart's origin. Episode 3, "Outkast," presented a stark departure from the comics, focusing heavily on his background, race, and the specific circumstances of his selection as a Green Lantern. This bold narrative choice has polarized viewers, with some praising the show's willingness to explore new thematic territory and others feeling it disrespects the established lore.

"How the f* was I not supposed to be scared? Got lifted out of my bed. I was in a…a bubble." — John Sr.

This deviation from the source material, while sparking controversy, has undeniably made for a more engaging and talked-about series. The dynamic between the "old timer" Hal and the "rookie" John, initially lauded as a buddy-comedy setup, has now been tested by these internal and external pressures, making their journey all the more compelling for viewers invested in the nuances of their relationship and their place within the wider DC mythos.

What's Next

The repercussions of "Lights Out" and the ongoing exploration of John Stewart's altered origin will undoubtedly shape the remainder of Lanterns' first season. Fans will be watching closely to see if Hal and John can overcome their animosity and if the show will further explore the darker corners of the Green Lantern universe.