Monster and The Traitors Drop New Seasons: What to Watch Thursday

Get ready, binge-watchers! This Thursday, September 17, 2026, brings a double dose of must-watch television with the highly anticipated premieres of Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story on Netflix and The Traitors: New Blood on NBC. For fans of Ryan Murphy's Monster anthology series, the latest installment dives deep into one of history's most infamous unsolved mysteries. The show promises to explore the life and alleged crimes of Lizzie Borden, a figure whose name has become synonymous with a brutal axe murder that shocked a nation. The series is expected to dissect the events leading up to and following the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, offering a fresh, albeit fictionalized, perspective on the case that has captivated true crime enthusiasts for generations. The Netflix release makes it readily available for global audiences eager to dissect every clue and performance.

Meanwhile, the world of strategic deception and social manipulation gets a major boost with the debut of The Traitors: New Blood on NBC. This latest iteration of the hit reality competition promises to bring back the intense psychological gameplay that made its predecessors so addictive. The format, which pits unsuspecting contestants against a secret group of 'traitors' aiming to sabotage their efforts, is renowned for its dramatic reveals and backstabbing. The show will also be available for streaming the next day on Peacock, ensuring that even those who can't catch it live can join the water-cooler conversation. The teaser from NBC highlighted the core appeal: "Ordinary people. Extraordinary deceit." This season is poised to deliver the same thrilling blend of strategy, paranoia, and unexpected alliances that has cemented The Traitors as a dominant force in reality television.

What Fans Are Saying

The online buzz surrounding both premieres is palpable. Social media feeds are alight with discussions about the potential for Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story to deliver another captivating, albeit chilling, performance, much like previous seasons of the Monster franchise. Fans are eager to see how the show will tackle the complex narrative of Lizzie Borden, with many speculating about the creative liberties Ryan Murphy and his team will take. For The Traitors: New Blood, the anticipation is equally high. Viewers are already debating who might be a traitor, sharing their favorite moments from past seasons, and predicting which contestants will crack under the pressure. The community aspect of The Traitors is a significant draw, with fans dissecting every move and confession, making it a truly interactive viewing experience. The dual release ensures that fans have compelling content across different genres, catering to diverse tastes within the dedicated viewing community.

What's Next

Both Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story and The Traitors: New Blood premiere on Thursday, September 17, 2026. Monster will be available on Netflix, while The Traitors airs on NBC and streams the following day on Peacock. Viewers should prepare for a week filled with dark history and thrilling deception.